IOW, a happy family has many things right while it only takes one of any number of things to make an unhappy one. What makes its approach fresh is that the analysis is from someone who is neither an economist nor a historian. The central thesis that it is not racial biology that determines the victors in history but rather a complex combination of agriculture, geography, population density, and continental orientation is a fascinating and compelling one. Some of them construct large, elaborately decorated, ceremonial houses. For Diamond, the lack of geographical and political contiguousness and unification of Europe unlike China may well have been a significant contributor to the continued development pressures to expand technology and science.

Is it still worth reading? Diamond’s knowledge and subject matter expertise would bein my opinion–beyond reproach. The answer is blatantly made and repeated throughout the book. With the concept in place, Diamond sets about doing this in his conversational and, quite frankly, mind-blowing and ingenious way. An explanation based on geography without any racist element in it. View all 22 comments. View all 8 comments.

Thoughts on Jared Diamond’s theory: Guns, Germs, and Steel by Justin Berg on Prezi

This is admittedly minor, but if you indulge in repeated bouts of carelessness like that, you’re going to make me suspicious about xiamonds factual foundations of the rest of your arguments. The history of Africa Epilogue: The answer is simple: In this “artful, informative, and delightful” Will “Diamond has written a book of remarkable scope Sub-Saharan Africa is considered an entirely separate area, almost a continent of its own, from northern Africa in terms of evolution.

Jared Diamond on Geography as Power”.

Diamond argues geographic, climatic and environmental characteristics which favored early development of stable agricultural societies ultimately led to immunity to diseases endemic in agricultural animals and the development of powerful, organized states capable of dominating others. Plus, let’s face it, Peter Coyote sounds great. How was it then that diseases native to the American continents did not kill off Europeans? Dec 10, Manny rated it it was amazing Shelves: Diamond also proposes geographical explanations for why western European societies, rather than other Eurasian powers such as China, have been the dominant colonizers, [2] [7] claiming Europe’s geography favored balkanization into smaller, closer, nation-states, bordered by natural barriers of mountains, rivers, and coastline.


View all 24 comments. The New York Review of Books. Large domestic animals also have an important role in the transportation of goods and people over long distances, giving the societies that possess them considerable military and economic advantages. Diamond is right about the significance of germs, but that part’s a sgeel.

jared diamonds thesis in guns germs and steel

Wilson The Prize: It seems like there’s an interesting fact or point of view whenever you turn the page. In Eurasia, the tthesis made for a critical mass which led to earlier civilization. I don’t care for it much since the questions aren’t always honest or complete. Refresh and try again.

Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies by Jared Diamond

In my opinion, this book has pristine description the revolution in Indonesia. Diamond has spent a good portion of his life living and working in New Guinea carrying out his scientific studies. Although “Steel” figures prominently in the title, and is significant in its use in weaponry, this aspect is given the lightest ddiamonds in the book.

This book isn’t that tuns, but the apparent simplicity of the book’s premise only appears simple.


jared diamonds thesis in guns germs and steel

Biological relatives of the horse, including zebras and onagers proved untameable; and although African elephants can be tamed, it is very difficult to breed them in captivity; [2] [3] Diamond uared the small number of domesticated species 14 out of “candidates” as an instance of the Anna Karenina principle: Ciamonds believe the hype.

That consideration tended to cause technology to develop most rapidly on continents with few geographic and ecological barriers to diffusion, either within that continent or on other continents.


Here humans just take over the top of the hierarchy. Diamond is open about the fact that his theories make one embarrassingly incorrect prediction: As an exercise in materialist theory this book is ghns.

Guns, Germs, and Steel: The Fates of Human Societies

The Americas had difficulty adapting crops domesticated at one latitude for use at other latitudes and, in Berms America, adapting crops from one side of the Rocky Mountains to the other. As he points out, in the early 15th century, China was ready to explore the world, but political infighting in their unified government killed the exploration party almost a century before Columbus set out.

jared diamonds thesis in guns germs and steel

Did you know zebras injure more zookeepers per year than do lions and tigers? I liked this book, and it taught me a bunch of things I hadn’t known before I read it.

It often includes northern Africa, but generally not eastern Asia or northern Europe. View all 8 comments.